May 8, 2025 at 1:20 p.m.
Slight slip
BERNE — After Avery Brown and Lindsey LeFever reached base to start the third inning of a scoreless game, Mallory Winner worked an 0-2 count on Bekah Patterson.
Foul ball.
Foul.
Ball one.
Foul.
Foul.
Ball two.
Foul.
Foul.
Ball three.
Ball four.
It took 12 pitches, but Patterson drew the walk to load the bases.
Shelby Weigel made Winner pay for the mistake.
While the Jay County High School softball team’s offense struggled to get going, the Class 2A No. 5 South Adams Starfires scored all three runs in the third inning for a 3-1 victory on Wednesday.
“Of course they’re a good ball team,” said JCHS coach Doug Arbuckle. “They’re ranked and got a solid pitcher. Runs are going to be scarce when you play a team like that more than likely. I thought we could have done a little better job at the plate with our approach with some of our at bats. … To be honest, we haven’t seen that many caliber pitchers this year. So it’s good to see here now than down the road here in a couple of weeks for the sectional.”
The Starfires (12-2, 2-1 Allen County Athletic Conference) got runners in scoring position in three innings, but they only managed to make it to the plate in the third.
Brown sent Winner’s first pitch of the inning to shallow right field to give South Adams its first hit of the game. LeFever worked a full count before drawing a walk to put two runners on with no outs.
Winner got Patterson to swing at the first pitch and foul off the second to go up 0-2. The JCHS senior just couldn’t finish her off as Patterson fouled off six more pitches before drawing a walk.
After the long at bat, Winner fell behind Weigel 2-1 in the count. The SAHS second baseman sent the fourth pitch to the gap between center and right field, plating all three runners.
“Mallory had a good game and she battled and we had a couple of walks,” Arbuckle said. “(Patterson) had that good at bat there with about 10 or 11 pitches and worked a walk and then of course they come up with the big hit. In a low scoring game like this, that’s key, when you get runners on base and you can get that one big hit.”
While the Starfires managed to put together a big inning, Jay County (11-2, 1-2 ACAC), which finished 11th in the Class 3A coaches poll, couldn’t break through against Addie Baker.
Through the first six innings, the Patriots only had three base runners on a first-inning single by Jaelynn Lykins and walks from Hallie Schwieterman and Jozey Shimp in the second and fourth frames.
South Adams didn’t take the Patriots’ lineup lightly, as their dugout noted how Jay County came back from a 3-0 deficit to No. 6 Woodlan on Saturday. So when Brenna Ruble worked a 3-0 count to start the sixth inning, SAHS coach Jessie O’Dell took a trip out to talk to Baker. The senior pitcher responded with three consecutive strikes to put Ruble down.
Baker followed with a six-pitch strikeout of Morgan Missicano and got Lykins to ground out to second base on the first pitch.
Photo Gallery
Jay County softball at South Adams (5/7/2025)
Jay County posed another threat in the seventh inning as Shimp and Winner opened with back-to-back singles. With no outs and two runners on, O’Dell took another trip out to the mound.
“‘Be sharp,’” O’Dell recalled telling Baker and his infield. “‘Trust our training.’ We really hone in fundamentals and not throwing the ball around. If they score a run, they score a run, but we don’t want to make this a big inning. ‘You don’t have to do anything extra.’ And I thought the kids responded and did a great job.”
Baker got Schweiterman to fly out to right field, but Shimp tagged up to advance to third base in the process.
In the following at bat, Carley Trinidad hit a high pop up in the foul territory outside the left handed batters box. Despite Reagan Bollenbacher and Reagan Beitler, the catcher and third baseman, colliding on the play, the latter managed to hold onto the ball for the out. While the two were on the ground, Winner tagged up to take second base.
Shimp finally came around to score on the second pitch of Ava Bice’s at bat when she swung at a high pitch that got past Bollenbacher. While Winner made it up to third on the same passed ball, she never scored as Baker ended the game by catching Bice looking at the second and third strikes.
The Patriots have now lost two of their last three games (all three games came against ranked teams) and both defeats have come to conference opponents. They will need to have a short memory to avoid any further slide when they take on Bluffton on Thursday.
“I told the girls I’ve got a little thing called the STM,” Arbuckle said. “It’s called short term memory. So we get to come back and play another game tomorrow night. We’ll see how we come back and answer tomorrow night at home against Bluffton. … You’ve just got to move on, learn something from it and put it to the best of your ability.”
Box score
Jay County Patriots vs. Class 2A No. 5 South Adams Starfires
Jay County (11-2, 1-2 ACAC)
abrhbi
Ruble ss3000
Missicano cf3000
Lykins c3010
May cr0000
Shimp 1b2110
Plessinger pr0000
Winnner p3010
Schwieterman rf2000
Trinidad 2b3000
Bice lf3000
CBrown 3b2000
Totals24130
South Adams (12-2, 2-1 ACAC)
abrhbi
Patterson cf2100
Weigel 2b2013
Baker p3000
Nnschwndr 1b3010
CBllnbchr pr0000
Beitler 3b3000
Bernard dp3000
RBollenbacher c2000
ABrown lf2120
LeFever rf0100
Totals20343
Jay County0000001 — 1
So. Adams003000X — 3
LOB — Jay County 4, South Adams 3. 2B — South Adams 1 (Weigel). SB — Jay County 1 (Schwieterman), South Adams 1 (Patterson).
IPHRERBBSO
Jay County
Winner533335
Trinidad110002
South Adams
Baker731028
Top Stories
9/11 NEVER FORGET Mobile Exhibit
Chartwells marketing
September 17, 2024 7:36 a.m.